Which record that you know in your heart is a bit shit has given you most joy over the years?

Matthew Ryan vs The Silver State is a proper safe place album for me. Always put it on when I’m sad. Guess it’s fairly MOR Americana. Nobody I’ve ever played it to has liked it. One of my pals posted me back a copy I bought him online and said it sounded like Rod Stewart.

Shoot…

Neutral milk hotels

Very Fast Very Dangerous by Reuben

2 Likes

America’s Least Wanted by Ugly Kid Joe

2 Likes

Powderfinger
Embrace

2 Likes

This is a tough one because I genuinely think they’re amazing (their first four albums in particular are all-time classics, I will never back down from this), but maybe I’ll go with 311’s From Chaos. It’s just a blast start to finish despite containing significant levels of shit.

Maybe even my favorite song by them, it’s so fucking good.

Another great one

Total Shit

Decent song but lyrically I can’t. Their ridiculous lyrics are part of the charm but “If dealing with punks was school, I’d have a Harvard degree” is a bridge too far.

Katy Perry’s catalogue.

Panic Prevention - Jamie T

1 Like

617uFeCpI+L.UXNaN_FMjpg_QL85

1 Like

Stadium Arcadium

1 Like

It was 2003

Not sure I can say I got loads of joy from it, but secretly quite enjoyed The Music’s self-titled (and perhaps only?) album, despite knowing it is quite terrible proper haircut stuff.

5 Likes

Blue Pearl - Naked.

I’m sure it’s rubbish, but I loved it too much in my youth to notice. It also introduced me to ‘Running Up That Hill’ so led me to Kate Bush, so that buys it points. It also has David Gilmour playing guitar on a couple of tracks!

All of the classic ones.

1 Like

Manowar_kingsofmetalsalbumcover

It’s rubbish but it’s great.

4 Likes

IMG_1562

10 Likes

Dude Ranch

2 Likes
1 Like

I got a fair bit of joy from the singles on Chocolate Starfish when I was younger, but would now say that album is properly shit while SO is at least ok

Yeah, was considering that at first.