Worst comeback ever?


#1

European fascism. Wahey! #currentevents Er, seriously. I’m not sure. Every time Oasis or the Gallaghers have released a new record since 1997? Heard bad things about the recent Black Flag album, still too scared to listen to it a few years on


#2

My Vitriol


#3

I know you are but what am I


#4

A garbage man


#5

Nah that’s deep blue!!!


#6

Gotta be MV for the way they have alienated their fans


#7


#8

Pixies has pretty bad, awful music, lost a key band member


#9

Pixies’ come back has been so bad it has almost retroactively wiped them out of musical history


#10

The bloke from Ride wore that hat


#11

That was Razorlight


#12

They’ve just had a 3 year album cycle haven’t they?


#13

Honourable mention to Guns ‘n’ Roses:

An album title that was nearly stolen by The Offspring:


#14

Depends, if you’re after breaking up a bands legacy and ruining a good thing then yeah… the above… the bassist from joy division singing their songs :confused:

But for comical… S club 3 is pretty shit… even by their standards


#15

I didn’t have high expecations for it, but that new Jesus and Mary Chain album was worse than I thought it would be. It didn’t help that a couple tracks appeared in superior forms elsewhere.


#16

5ive when they came back with four of them.


#17

It’s been a long time since I’ve listened to either but I always thought that the My Bloody Valentine and Soundgarden comebacks were disappointing. If mbv had been released by a new band I don’t think it would have gotten any attention at all, and King Animal (with the exception of “By Crooked Steps”) was like a plodding slow death. And one of the songs if I remember correctly was a complete watering down of “Holy Water” off of Badmotorfinger, they didn’t even try to disguise it at all.


#18

maybe, hadn’t heard of them apart from the DiS joke for over a decade.


#19

Given how bad Chinese Democracy should be, it’s actually ok.


#20

That Jane’s Addiction album from the mid-00s was total shite. And second someone’s shout of Soundgarden. Ooof. So dull.

Also: Blur’s ‘Magic Whip’. Yawnsville.