šŸ§™ šŸ§™ā€ā™€ļø zap zap let's have a fantasy thread zap zap šŸ§™ā€ā™€ļø šŸ§™

I’ve heard the first couple of books are a bit iffy, but that it gains strength as it progresses

1 Like

Half way through book two of Way of Kings and this is exactly how I feel. I’m enjoying it but the magic isn’t there (ironically).

It’s unfair to compare fantasy series to Tolkien but, fuck it, with all the backstory and the Silmarillion and so on, JRRT feels like a writer trying to convince you that there is order to things when underneath it all there is mystery and the unexplained. Sanderson feels like a writer trying to convince me that there is mystery and the unexplained in his world but really I think there is order: there are neat little answers to questions about his universe and if I keep plodding through the stories long enough he’ll keep doling them out to me.

1 Like

I mean Sanderson is a very modern writer, which means a large chunk of his mysteries are because the reader (or viewer, as this is all I very TV/film) is not provided the full story, whereas a classic mystery is based on the character the reader/viewer follows not having the full story. IMO anyway

1 Like

That’s an interesting way of putting it. I quite like Donaldson’s take of ā€œI am absolutely not going to explain magicā€ for this sort of thing. The idea that the magic is so far beyond human understanding that there may as well not be rules.

Sanderson is the opposite. Everything links together and works like a physics system and honestly I do like it, but it removes a lot of the sense of mystery that better fantasy thrives on.

1 Like

Honestly option A is closer to the real world. Like I can do maths in my head that most people struggle with, but run like someone with no cerebellum. Why? Dunno, neurons and stuff.

1 Like

It’s very popular at the moment in fantasy in general I think, the idea of a very structured rule-based magic system. Like the rise of ā€œside questsā€ in table-top RPGs, I think it’s computer game RPGs reinforming an ā€œanalogueā€ medium because computer games are now people’s entry to the genre much more than where they finally landed. Maybe?

1 Like

Yeah, I almost said it feels very computer gamey. In Mistborn it’s almost like the characters had skill trees they were progressing down.

As a lifelong gamer I am entirely ok with games informing other media, but it does make it feel very different to more traditional approaches.

1 Like

I’m not ok with it! Magic is such such a hard thing to get right and I totally get why you need to have checks and balances otherwise the whole thing can topple into absurdity ā€œand then the goodies won because magic happened!ā€

However, however, there needs to be mystery for it to feel like magic. Gandalf is a perfect example. His powers are limited, holding the Balrog at bay before his final confrontation with it clearly saps him and yet he’s allowed a mystical resurrection because… Magic. It’s ineffable, unknowable. In a tabletop or computer RPG it has to be rule bound. You can’t take down Gannon or Ornstein and Smough because you feel like it but in books there needs to be room for awe and wonder.

4 Likes

Finished Tchaikovsky’s Days of Shattered Faith at the weekend, the third in his Tyrant Philosophers series. I really enjoyed it, imo this might be the best series he’s done, certainly the most consistent so far.

5 Likes

Book four is just as good. :grin:

3 Likes

Yep, nearing the end of four. Two still edges it for me, but all four (plus the novella) are great.

1 Like

I’d agree with this.

3 Likes

Liveship Traders finished. I think I may have largely preferred the setting to the Farseer trilogy, but not the characters, though Ronica was excellent.

Will be doing some none Hobb reading for a bit.

But, which series should I get of hers next?

2 Likes

Tawny Man next!!

2 Likes

I’m on book 2 of the final trilogy right now.

I just know I’m going to be devastated.

I cried every day I read The Tawny Man trilogy.

Fool’ Quest spoilers but it’s pissing me off just how gormless this man is. He always has been but this is just too frustratingly done.My child has been stolen… the kidnappers are after the unexpected son… they must have taken my pale odd child as a hostage to swap!!

1 Like

Yeah I loved liveship traders so much that I went straight into Rain Wild Chronicles, which was great from a ā€œstay with the settingā€ perspective but I did regret not reading Tawny Man first. I agree to go for Tawny Man next!

1 Like

Posted in the wrong thread

3 Likes

Started my re-read of Guards! Guards! this morning. Not read it since it came out. Annoyed I had to put it down to start work.

3 Likes

Might have to (re)read a Pratchett soon, I’ve been picking up the kindle versions whenever they’re 99p and have a few now. I had pretty much all the Discworld books in paperback from when they originally came out but recently sold them to a mate for Ā£20 as they were just sat in a box in the loft, he probably got quite a bargain there!

1 Like

In a very similar position to you actually. I have ereaderIQ setup to tell me when is books are on offer. I only had paperbacks up to about 13 though which is where I stopped so most are new to me when I get them.

The entire Watch series was on special recently so that’s how come I got it. Trying to stick to numeric order when I have a bunch to read rather than ā€˜series’. Seems I have 22, the majority unread. I kept TCoM and TLF in paperback as they were my OGs