💿 How Good Is It Really 💿 Funeral

Also shout out to the Canadian hipster I met at a house party who loved thst I’d been to Bolton - “Bolton is the home of the donk!” - and told people how he knew the AF drummer - “man, he was the best drummer in Ottawa”

7 Likes

SIX

lovely.

2 Likes

Really good to be honest

Also Win Butler looks like Richie from Bottom in the Rebellion video and it’s moderately funny

It’s a 10 from me. I love it. I came to it with apprehension as I am a big constellation fan and NMH, but they won me over really quickly. I saw them at Reading in 2005 when they were touring funeral and they were so good. Glad to have seen them for each album and they are always brilliant live.

2 Likes

10/10. Probably my favourite debut ever. Wish I’d seen them around this time, but managed to catch them around Neon Bible. The energy and intensity of funeral is something to behold

5 Likes

Trying to imagine who’s doing the arguing here. You and a friend? Split personalities?

Sgreen: Funeral is definitely my favourite album of all time
Sgreen’s interlocutor: You think? I reckon Radiohead’s Kid A is probably your favourite. Look at how often you play it.
Sgreen: Nah, I’m telling you: I like Funeral more than any othe album. Means so much to me. The sequencing is unreal, the best songs flow from mellow indie-orchestra to ragged anthemic rock, and the album as a whole reflects this too. Production-wise, it pretty much sounds like it was recorded in a basement but it completely works.
Sgreen’s interlocutor: You’re wrong, mate. There’s probably half a dozen albums you like better than Funeral


1 Like

This is just about the easiest 10/10 of all of them so far.

2 Likes

9/10, but only because Turn On The Bright Lights is 10/10 and it’s not quite as good as that. Picture dump below of their Leadmill show in 2005. It was so good. Got my ticket signed after too (Regine did the smiley face).





18 Likes

me reading posts like this in these threads:

15 Likes

Wi, Wils, пilп and пeep are definitely my top 4 members

2 Likes

That’s just crazy talk.

I found Neon Bible a huge disappointment at the time, but it did slowly grow on me. But, it’s not in the same league as Funeral which is so far beyond anything else they (or pretty much any other band) have done.

I do like all their albums though except the last one which
 well let’s just not talk about it and hope it’s just an anomaly.

“I GUESS WE’LL JUST HAVE TO ADJUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUAAAAAAAHHHHHHOOOOOHHHHOOOOJHOOOJHOOOOHHWWOOOOOOOOOOO” is still one of the most skin pricking moments of music
absolutely brings tears to my eyes when belting it out in the car

9 Likes

neon bible > suburbs > funeral

That is very cool. £11 well spent!

1 Like

I was there too. I don’t know whether it was just the extreme amount of pre- gig hype which set my expectations unreasonably high or whether they were having an off night, but I don’t remember greatly enjoying it.

Great, great album. One of my biggest gig regrets is that I had tickets to see them at the Academy in Bristol around this time and was well up for it, but when the night rolled round, the wife and I were both really ill and couldn’t have driven from Cardiff to Bristol. If I was to see them now it’d be a much bigger venue and they’d probably play some songs from the albums that came after Neon Bible so it wouldn’t be as much fun. Still gutted about it, and @brightlight’s photo extravaganza from the same tour is not helping matters, no sir.

Trying far too hard there
 Smh

The next time I saw them (Manchester Apollo, Neon Bible tour) was the opposite, it felt flat and just wasn’t the same. Though Leadmill I was front row, and you can’t really fail to be swept up with it then.