The Independent's 25 Most Overrated Albums

Music
, , ,
1

25. Madonna – Confessions on a Dance Floor
24. The Beatles – Sgt Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band
23. Billie Eilish – When We All Fall Asleep, Where Do We Go?
22. PJ Harvey– Let England Shake
21. Lorde - Pure Heroine
20. David Bowie – Low
19. The White Stripes – Elephant
18. Self Esteem – Prioritise Pleasure
17. U2 – Songs of Innocence
16. Taylor Swift – The Tortured Poets Department
15. Bruce Springsteen and the E Street Band – Letter to You
14. Sex Pistols – Never Mind the Bollocks, Here’s the Sex Pistols
13. Boygenius – The Record
12. Van Morrison – Astral Weeks
11. Arctic Monkeys – Tranquility Base Hotel + Casino
10. The 1975 – A Brief Inquiry Into Online Relationships
9. Jeff Buckley – Grace
8. Coldplay – Parachutes
7. Nirvana – In Utero
6. Led Zeppelin – Led Zeppelin IV
5. Florence + The Machine – Lungs
4. Captain Beefheart & His Magic Band – Trout Mask Replica
3. The Horrors – Primary Colours
2. Radiohead – Kid A
1. Interpol – Turn on the Bright Lights

Lists are the original rage bait, when you think about it.

3 Likes
2

21 appears to be Lorde’s ‘Pure Heroine’. To think that someone got paid for this.

3

Ah yeah, they just forgot the title, I’ll amend the list, ta.

4

In fairness, most of that list is pretty spot on.

12 Likes
5

Good list. Something for everyone there

9 Likes
6

This is very clickbaity/ragebaity but they should have Stone Roses - ST at no.1 really

14 Likes
7

:man_shrugging: AM should have been the Arctic Monkeys record.

4 Likes
8

Actually hard to argue with a lot of that. Buckley, Kid A, Trout Mask Replica, U2, Sex Pistols should be the top 5 though.

1 Like
9

Are The Horrors even big enough to feature that highly?

13 Likes
10

Some very upsetting, some I can get behind

1 Like
11

I think “historical importance” is a bit of a stretch for anything released on the last five years.

5 Likes
12

Yeah that’s a good list. I like primary colours but can’t argue tha it’s not overrated.

Might argue “Grace” as I don’t think it is spoken of as reverently post-hallelujah, but I’m not really fussed.

13

Very strong no 1 pick though, good stuff

2 Likes
14

It’s not a bad list. I’m surprised that it doesn’t include more obvious generational sacred cows like London Calling, TDSOTM, even Airplane over the Sea.

1 Like
15

Outrageous

They got The Horrors spot on though

16

Between this and the Pitchfork “re-review” of TOTBL, I can’t figure out why the critical re-evaluation is happening now.

I know the recent stuff isn’t great but it hasn’t been for 10+ years.

17

Millenial Journalists are just discovering Joy Division & are realising their formative band was a tribute outfit maybe

3 Likes
18

The whole concept of ‘overrated’ is just an invitation to edgelord wankery - ‘oh, lots of people like this, just imagine how cool and edgy I’ll seem when I tell them it’s actually shit’.

31 Likes
19

If they didn’t realise they were quite similar to Joy Division in the first place then they shouldn’t have been journalists

20

:100:

1 Like