🎵 How Good Are They Really 🎵 Neil Young

Ragged Glory, Rust Never Sleeps, American Stars n Bars

EDIT: meant to be a reply, not just a random list of three albums

2 Likes

Writing an essay in my head for this thread for tomorrow.

5 Likes

Harvest Moon > the moon landings

Will listen to this later! Sorry been at work. Excited to hear how it is whether it’s faithful to the original or whether it’s fuzzed and amped up!

1 Like

It is the original! Recorded over ten years before the one on Everybody’s Rockin’!

Harvest Moon > A Moon Shaped Pool >>>> Pablo Honey

5 Likes

Marquee Moon > Moon Pix > Moon Safari > Dark Side Of The Moon > Harvest Moon

5 Likes

We can’t have a hgatr thread without sun kil moon

1 Like

Don’t know who he is pal.

2 Likes

Marquee Moon > Ban Ki Moon > Harvest Moon > The moon > Fly Me To The Moon > moonpig.com

7 Likes

Nor do I

1 Like

Ban Ki Moon has done me.

1 Like

Eeek! I’m sorry m8 had a listen but I think I prefer the Everybody’s Rockin’ version :no_mouth:

Diamond Lights > Neil Diamond > Diamond White > Diamonds From Sierra Leone > 4 of diamonds

1 Like

Whaaaat? Have a listen to the live album it’s from, one of my favourite Neil releases!

1 Like

Shitting brilliant it is

1 Like

Sorry bud, genuinely think it suits that 50’s jukebox style better, there’s even essence of that in this live version. The Filmore version starts out almost Velvet Underground - ish but still ends up not a million miles away from the Everybody’s Rockin’ version imo…

Really didn’t expect myself to be so heavily advocating Everybody’s Rockin’ today / in any thread ever :sweat_smile:

3 Likes

If there’s ever an Iggy / Stooges HGATR then expect some nonsensical rambling about Party and Blah Blah Blah too Sorry in advance, honestly

1 Like

I have it on now, bizarre how similar Neil’s vocal is between the two versions! I’m always goimg to prefer the live version, the production on the studio version is atrocious!

2 Likes